The Risks of Disavowing Links: Why a Thoughtful Strategy Is a Key

8 Jun

The Risks of Disavowing Links: Why a Thoughtful Strategy Is a Key

In the world of Search Engine Optimization (SEO), link building plays a critical role in shaping a website’s visibility and ranking in search results. Webmasters strive to improve their site’s performance by evaluating backlinks through third-party metrics during technical site audits. They utilize tools like Google’s disavow tool to disavow links based on these audit reports

While these metrics offer insights into the quality of links, it’s important to understand their limitations. In this blog post, we will delve into the reasons why disavowing links based on third-party metrics is a flawed approach.

Reasons Why You Should Never Disavow Links Based on Third-Party

Google’s John Mueller strongly advises against using third-party tool metrics to disavow links. He believes it is a “terrible idea” and that Google does not consider those metrics important.

Let’s have a look at some strong reasons to never consider third-party applications for disavowing links.

The Limitations of Third-Party Metrics

Third-party metrics, such as Domain Authority (DA) or Page Rank, have their place in quantifying the authority and quality of a website or specific web pages. However, when it comes to on-page SEO, blindly disavowing links based solely on these metrics can lead to misguided decisions. To achieve optimal results, it’s crucial to consider the broader context of your website’s content and ensure that all links are related to your industry.

Ignoring Context and Relevance

In the realm of technical site audits, disavowing links solely based on metrics ignore the importance of context and relevance. A link from a reliable and pertinent source within your industry can still be valuable to your website even if it has a lower metric score. Incorporating on-page and off-page SEO strategies can help you capitalize on potential opportunities for referral traffic and establish connections with relevant communities.

Adapting to Algorithmic Changes

Search engine algorithms constantly evolve, rendering third-party metrics alone insufficient for evaluating the quality of links. What might be considered a low-quality link today based on these metrics might not necessarily hold true in the future. By conducting a comprehensive technical SEO audit, you can adapt to algorithmic shifts and focus on the overall quality and relevance of your backlink profile.

Protecting Against Potential Negative SEO Attacks

Relying on third-party metrics for disavowing links can make your website vulnerable to negative SEO attacks. Competitors or malicious entities may intentionally create low-quality or spammy backlinks to your site, causing your metrics to decline. Instead of solely relying on metrics, a thorough analysis of the link’s source, relevance, and overall impact on your website’s performance should be conducted. Implementing technical site audit services can help identify and mitigate negative SEO threats effectively.

Balancing Metrics with a Diverse Backlink Profile

A healthy backlink profile encompasses a diverse range of links from different sources and domains. Disavowing links based solely on metrics can lead to a narrow and limited backlink profile. Emphasizing relevance and trustworthiness should take precedence over blindly following third-party metrics and creating a strong foundation for on-page and off-page SEO.

Lack of Transparency and Incomplete Data

Third-party metrics often lack transparency, making it challenging to make informed decisions solely based on these metrics. To ensure effective on-page, off-page, and technical SEO, it’s crucial to understand how scores are calculated and the quality of links is determined. Engaging with a reputable SEO services company that offers comprehensive technical SEO audit services can provide you with the necessary transparency and access to complete data for making informed decisions.

Maximizing Positive Link Signals for SEO Success

By considering the metrics of third-party applications, you risk losing positive link signals that could contribute to your website’s SEO efforts. Even links from lower-metric sources can provide relevant and high-quality content that positively impacts your website’s authority and visibility in search results. Disavowing such links unnecessarily can result in missed opportunities for organic growth. Incorporating a holistic approach to SEO strategy ensures that positive link signals are not overlooked.


While third-party metrics can provide valuable insights into the quality of backlinks, disavowing links solely based on these metrics is not recommended. It is crucial to consider a holistic approach that encompasses on-page & off-page SEO and technical SEO audit services. By analyzing factors such as source credibility, relevance, and overall impact, you can build a diverse and robust backlink profile that maximizes the effectiveness of your SEO strategy.


Nitish Sharma

He is a Digital Marketing Professional with 8+ years of work experience and vast knowledge of various Digital Marketing techniques and platforms. He has honed his expertise over the years, making him adept at navigating the dynamic landscape of online marketing. With his wealth of experience, he has successfully executed numerous digital campaigns and strategies, driving significant results for businesses across different industries.

Follow Us:


For all questions, you can contact
our international call center, which
works 24/7

+1(306) 993 6888 Read More


Get the new products in your inbox every day. Get the latest content first.

Still deciding on which top-notch service to use?
Let our team help you choose.

Let's Talk

Ready to drive more website traffic and Boost sales? Connect with us!

Let's help you win more customers.

Send us a message!